about us

Q&A: Appealing a Criminal Conviction

Malcolm Seawell

Nov 16 2026 14:00

A criminal conviction may feel final, but Colorado law provides a process for asking a higher court to review certain issues that occurred in the trial court. An appeal is not a second trial or an opportunity to present a case again from the beginning. Instead, it is a focused legal review of whether significant errors affected the fairness or outcome of the proceedings.

At the Law Offices of Malcolm B. Seawell, we provide clear, straightforward guidance to people facing serious criminal matters in Centennial, the Denver metro area, and throughout Colorado. Understanding the criminal appeals process, the deadlines involved, and the issues that may support appellate review can help a defendant and their family make informed decisions after a conviction.

What Is a Criminal Appeal?

A criminal appeal is a formal request for an appellate court to examine a conviction, sentence, or other ruling made by a trial court. The appellate court generally does not hear new witness testimony, receive new evidence, or decide which witnesses were more believable. Its review is usually limited to the record created in the original case.

That record can include motions filed before and after trial, admitted exhibits, transcripts of hearings and trial testimony, the court's rulings, jury instructions, and written arguments submitted by the attorneys. Appellate judges review these materials to decide whether the law was applied correctly and whether a legal mistake had a meaningful effect on the result.

In some cases, the appellate court also holds oral argument. During oral argument, the attorneys may explain their positions and answer questions from the panel of judges. The central purpose remains the same: determining whether the original proceedings were conducted according to the law.

Who May Appeal a Criminal Conviction?

In general, a defendant convicted after a criminal trial may have the right to seek appellate review. The route for an appeal depends on where the case was prosecuted. A Colorado criminal case commonly proceeds first to the appropriate state appellate court, while a federal conviction is generally appealed to the relevant United States Circuit Court of Appeals.

If an initial appeal does not result in relief, further review may sometimes be requested from the state’s highest court. In limited circumstances, a party may seek review by the United States Supreme Court. Whether additional review is available depends on the procedural posture of the case and the legal questions involved.

Deadlines are especially important. In federal criminal matters, a notice of appeal may be due as soon as 14 days after the relevant judgment or order. State deadlines vary, but many jurisdictions allow approximately 30 days. Missing a deadline can jeopardize the ability to pursue an appeal, which is why prompt action is essential.

What Reasons Can Support an Appeal?

An appeal cannot rest solely on disagreement with a verdict or dissatisfaction with a sentence. A defendant must generally identify a legal issue that may have undermined the fairness of the trial or affected its outcome. A careful review of the record is necessary to determine whether a viable appellate issue exists.

Common issues raised in criminal appeals include:

  • Errors during trial: The trial court may have improperly admitted or excluded evidence, given incorrect instructions to the jury, or made another procedural or legal ruling that affected the case.
  • Ineffective assistance of counsel: A claim may arise when an attorney’s performance fell below an objective standard of reasonable representation and that deficiency had a meaningful impact on the outcome.
  • Juror misconduct: Jurors are required to follow the court’s instructions. Improper conduct during trial or deliberations may raise concerns about whether the process was fair.
  • Constitutional violations: An appeal may address violations of constitutional protections during an investigation, arrest, or trial when those violations affected the criminal proceedings.

Every case is different. An experienced Colorado criminal defense lawyer can assess the procedural history, court record, and applicable legal standards to identify issues that may warrant further review.

What Happens During the Appeals Process?

The appellate process differs substantially from a trial. It is not a forum for calling additional witnesses or presenting new physical evidence. Rather, appellate judges examine the established record and consider whether the trial court properly applied the law.

The attorneys ordinarily submit written briefs that explain the facts relevant to the appeal, identify the legal arguments, and cite the authority supporting each position. These briefs play a central role in appellate review. The opposing party submits a response, and further briefing may be permitted depending on the case.

When oral argument is scheduled, the attorneys appear before the appellate judges to address questions and clarify their legal positions. Once the court has reviewed the record, briefs, and any oral argument, it issues a written decision.

What Can an Appellate Court Decide?

If the appellate court finds a significant error, the available remedy depends on the nature of the problem and its effect on the case. The court may reverse a conviction, order a new trial, modify a sentence, or return the matter to the trial court for additional proceedings consistent with its ruling.

Not every legal error leads to a reversal. The court may determine that an error did not materially affect the result, or it may conclude that no reversible error occurred. In that event, the conviction or sentence may be affirmed.

If an intermediate court upholds the decision, there may still be an opportunity to request review from a higher court. These options are not automatic, and each requires close attention to procedural rules, filing requirements, and deadlines.

Why Is Timing So Important After a Conviction?

Time is one of the most consequential factors in a criminal appeal. The process starts soon after a conviction or sentencing, and strict filing deadlines apply. Waiting to explore options can limit the avenues available to a defendant.

Early legal guidance allows time to obtain and review the trial record, evaluate possible appellate arguments, and preserve important rights. This is particularly important for people who are unsure what happens after an arrest in Colorado, are facing the consequences of a DUI or other criminal conviction, or need clear information about the next legal step.

The Law Offices of Malcolm B. Seawell serves clients across Colorado with a structured and direct approach to criminal defense matters. For more than 30 years, our firm has helped clients understand complex legal situations and evaluate the options available to them.

FAQ

Is an appeal the same as a new trial?

No. A criminal appeal is generally not a new trial. The appellate court reviews the record from the existing case to determine whether legal errors occurred, rather than hearing new testimony or receiving new evidence.

How soon must I file a criminal appeal?

Appeal deadlines are strict and vary by court and jurisdiction. A federal notice of appeal may be due within 14 days, while many state courts allow approximately 30 days. Speaking with a Colorado attorney promptly after a conviction can help protect important filing rights.

Can I appeal because I believe the jury reached the wrong verdict?

Disagreement with the verdict alone is usually not enough. An appeal generally must identify a legal error, constitutional issue, juror misconduct, or another problem that may have affected the fairness or outcome of the trial.

What happens if my appeal is successful?

Depending on the issue and the appellate court’s decision, a successful appeal may result in a reversed conviction, a new trial, a modified sentence, or a return of the case to the trial court for further proceedings.

Can I seek more review if the appellate court denies my appeal?

Possibly. In some cases, a defendant may ask a higher state court to review the decision. Limited cases may also present grounds to seek review from the United States Supreme Court. The options depend on the specific facts and procedural history of the case.

If you or someone close to you has been convicted of a crime and needs guidance about a possible appeal, contact the Law Offices of Malcolm B. Seawell. Our Centennial-based firm assists clients throughout the Denver metro area and across Colorado in evaluating their criminal defense options and taking timely next steps.